===== PDF PAGE 28 ===== [Extraction: embedded PDF text] CITY OF WEST CHICAGO HISTORICAL PRESERVATION COMMISSION AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY ITEM TITLE: Window Replacement AGENDA ITEM NUMBER: 3 D. 119 Turner Court Guadalupe Perez COMMISSION AGENDA DATE: 06-25-24 C.O.A. # 24-12 STAFF REVIEW: John Sterrett, City Planner SIGNATURE__________________________ ITEM SUMMARY: Guadalupe Perez, owner of 119 Turner Court in the Turner Junction Historic District, is requesting ap- proval of a Certificate of Appropriateness application to replace two windows on the building façade along Turner Court. The façade of 119 Turner Court is the rear of 118 Main Street. The size of the windows as well as the color/type of trim of the replacement windows will be the same as the existing windows. The style of the proposed window, however, is sliding rather than the existing hung win- dows. No other changes or alterations to the building are proposed. Please see attached photos and window details for more information. The building is a Greek Revival constructed sometime between 1850 and 1870 and is contributing to the Historic District though it is not a candidate for local landmark status. ACTION PROPOSED: Consideration of replacement windows at 119 Turner Court. ===== PDF PAGE 29 ===== [Extraction: embedded PDF text] JELD-WEN® Better Series 60"W x 48"H Vinyl Left Sliding Window with Nailing Flange - White/White Model Number: JW1385-00852 Menards ® SKU: 4045516 EVERYDAY LOW PRICE $299.00 11% REBATE* Good Through 6/23/24 $32.89 PRICE 11 AFTER each $266 REBATE* You Save $32.89 with Mail-In Rebate* 92 People have purchased this in the past week. Vinyl construction allows for low maintenance Steel-reinforced sash for long-lasting strength Low-E glass with Argon reduces energy costs, interior condensation, and protects against harmful UV rays View More Information Rough Opening Size: 60"W X 48"H Pick Up At Store 4 In-Stock at Batavia Item located in Aisle 156 Section K View Shipping & Delivery Options Check Another Store for Availability Share ===== PDF PAGE 30 ===== [Extraction: embedded PDF text] Description & Documents Specifications Optional Accessories Product Type Sliding Windows Material Vinyl Collection Better Series Rough Opening Dimensions 60" W x 48" H Frame Width 59-1/2 inches Mounting Method With Nailing Flange (New Construction) Frame Height 47-1/2 inches Hardware Type Nylon Rollers and Cam-Lock Frame Depth 3-3/32 inches Hardware Finish White Screen Color White Glazing Type Double Pane Screen Material Charcoal Fiberglass Grid Pattern No Grid Exterior Color White Energy Star Zones Not Energy Star Certified Interior Color White U-Value 0.3 Air Leakage (AL) Rating 0.3 CFM Visible Light VT Rating 0.62 Solar Heat Gain Coefficient 0.51 Meets IRC for Egress Yes Special Features Screen, Brickmould, Low-E Manufacturer Warranty Lifetime Limited, Accidental Glass Breakage Warranty, Skilled Labor Coverage - 2 year Shipping Dimensions 62.25 H x 50.25 W x 3.50 D Shipping Weight 68.4375 lbs Return Policy Regular Return (view Return Policy) Compare - We've selected these items to compare. Let us help you decide which product fits your needs best! Currently Viewing JELD-WEN® Better Series Northview Aspen 24"W x JELD-WEN® Good Series JELD-WEN® Better Series JELD-WEN® Better Series 60"W x 48"H Vinyl Left 24"H White Vinyl Sliding 48"W x 48"H Vinyl Left 48"W x 24"H Vinyl Left 48"W x 48"H Vinyl Left Sliding Window with Window with Built-in J- Sliding Window with Sliding Window with Sliding Window with PRICE $299.00 PRICE $79.90 SALE PRICE $234.83 PRICE $225.00 PRICE $269.00 11% REBATE* $32.89 11% REBATE* $8.79 11% REBATE* $25.83 11% REBATE* $24.75 11% REBATE* $29.59 PRICE 11 PRICE 11 PRICE 00 PRICE 25 PRICE 41 AFTER AFTER AFTER AFTER AFTER each REBATE* $266 each REBATE* $71 each REBATE* $209 each REBATE* $200 each REBATE* $239 Delivery Delivery Delivery Delivery Delivery 4 In-Stock at BATAVIA 9 In-Stock at BATAVIA 4 In-Stock at BATAVIA 8 In-Stock at BATAVIA 5 In-Stock at BATAVIA ===== PDF PAGE 31 ===== [Extraction: no text detected] [No text detected on this page; page may be blank, photographic, or graphical.] ===== PDF PAGE 32 ===== [Extraction: OCR (rendered-page OCR)] a_i “ | ’ : _—_ | hI | = — | ql = | SS. | iuiN ieee 3 = | A * PS “a A "Y l CER a N = | = mam 6!‘ ||_cezass = a . aie SS TH / + “AY % S| BONSSs om v N } | | 2 > aA ‘il is al = — j ie A | ~X — : Recs: HAN 3 ] — | a F ~\ mz : z ay e. —=— = 7 8 ie CAL HH HY] it HEL He ===== PDF PAGE 33 ===== [Extraction: OCR (rendered-page OCR)] at, : Cea] es ieee i Ms ( 1 | iH ve f i ¥ & i ¥ J | | | | - F aa ae ===== PDF PAGE 34 ===== [Extraction: embedded PDF text] DRAFT WEST CHICAGO HISTORICAL PRESERVATION COMMISSION MEETING May 28, 2024 Members Present: City Staff: Vince Malina, Chairman Alderman Dan Beebe, City Council Liaison Keith Letsche, Vice Chairman John Sterrett, City Planner SueEllen Edwards Richard Vigsnes Wendy Christman Guests: Melissa Mercado, 137 Turner Court (via phone) Oscar Munoz, 102 Main Street Members Absent: Reverend Bill Andrews 1. Call to Order, Roll Call, and Establishment of a Quorum The meeting was called to order by Chairman Malina at 6:00 p.m. Roll call found Chairman Malina, Vice Chairman Letsche, and Commissioners Edwards, Vigsnes, and Christman present. Commissioner Andrews was absent. With five members present, a quorum was established. 2. Public Comment None 3. Certificate of Appropriateness Review A. C.O.A. 24-07 – 135 Turner Court – Awning Mr. Sterrett stated that Melissa Mercado, owner of 135 Turner Court in the Turner Junction Historic District, is requesting approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness application to install an awning on the building facing Turner Court. The proposed awning will be a traditional shed- style awning with no sides and will consist of Sunbrella fabric. The applicant is proposing a color of either Ocean Blue or a shade of teal, depending on the direction from the Commission. The awning will contain signage identifying the name of the business in the commercial space. Because of this, the awning will require approval of a sign permit to ensure the dimensions of the sign do not exceed the total allowable area permitted for signage. The façade of the building facing Turner Court is permitted to have a total of 97.5 square feet of signage. The applicant previously received approval in April for a 6 square foot wall sign. This leaves the building eligible for 91.5 square feet of additional signage. ===== PDF PAGE 35 ===== [Extraction: embedded PDF text] After a brief discussion, Chairman Malina made a motion, seconded by Vice Chair Letsche, to approve the COA application as presented with the color choice of teal for the awning. With a voice vote of all ayes the motion carried. B. C.O.A. 24-08 – 200 High Street – Parking Lot Repair/Replacement Mr. Sterrett stated that Vijay Kumar Gupta, owner of the apartment building at 200 High Street in the Turner Junction Historic District, is requesting approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness application to repair the existing parking lot. The applicant intends to remove approximately 5,140 square feet of existing asphalt down to the gravel. The gravel will be leveled and additional gravel will be added if needed. Four inches of N-50 asphalt will be installed and the lot will be restriped to original layout, including car stops. No other changes to the building or property are proposed. After a brief discussion, Chairman Malina made a motion, seconded by Commissioner Christman, to approve the COA application as presented. With a voice vote of all ayes the motion carried. C. C.O.A. 24-09 – 332 E Washington Street – Solar Panels Mr. Sterrett stated that the Rick Luckow, homeowner of 332 East Washington Street in the East Washington Street Historic District, is requesting approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness application to install rooftop solar panels on the subject house. The applicant intends to install 13 solar panels on the south side of the house, out of view from Washington Street. None of the panels will be installed on the north side of the house. The proposed location of these panels is on the rear of the house, away from Washington Street, and is consistent with previous approvals of solar panels on Washington Street. After a review of the submitted information, members of the Commission wanted to continue discussion on the proposal after additional information has been submitted. Chairman Malina made a motion, seconded by Vice Chair Letsche, to continue the discussion on the proposed COA application to next month. With a voice vote of all ayes the motion carried. 4. Preliminary Review Mr. Sterrett stated that Oscar Munoz, new owner of 102 Main Street, is proposing to renovate the existing façade on the rear of the building facing Turner Court. The entire façade is boarded up and the owner is proposing to install new windows and doors with glazing. After a discussion on the proposal, members of the Commission instructed the owner to redesign the plans so there is no transom for the doors and include a transom at the top of each window. The façade should match exactly how the façade previously looked with the same size and design. The owner stated he will revise his plans and will return to the Commission for further review. 5. Historic District/Landmark Updates A. Landmarking of Historic Homes Marketing Mr. Sterrett also stated that the City will begin the process of updating the historical buildings survey in the two districts as well as identifying other historic buildings outside the district in the surrounding neighborhoods. ===== PDF PAGE 36 ===== [Extraction: embedded PDF text] 6. Approval of January 23, 2024 Meeting Minutes Chairman Malina made a motion, seconded by Vigsnes, to approve the April 23, 2024 meeting minutes with the addition of City Council Liaison, Alderman Dan Beebe, to the minutes. With a voice vote of all ayes the motion carried. 7. Other Business Members of the Commission briefly discussed the status of the 200 Main Street façade project. 8. Adjournment Chairman Malina made a motion, seconded by Vice Chair Letsche, to adjourn the meeting. With a voice vote of all ayes the motion carried and the Historical Preservation Commission, at 7:07 p.m., adjourned. Respectfully submitted by John H. Sterrett, City Planner ===== PDF PAGE 37 ===== [Extraction: embedded PDF text] DRAFT MINUTES WEST CHICAGO HISTORICAL PRESERVATION COMMISSION MEETING March 28, 2023 Members Present: City Staff: Keith Letsche John Sterrett, City Planner Crystal Noland-Rianni Richard Vigsnes Guests: Wendy Christman Ronald Segert, 132 Fremont Street SueEllen Edwards Holly Perez, 312 E Washington Street Members Absent: Vince Malina Reverend Bill Andrews 1. Call to Order, Roll Call, and Establishment of a Quorum The meeting was called to order by Vice Chairman Letsche at 6:00 p.m. Roll call found Vice Chairman Letsche, and Commissioners Noland-Rianni, Edwards, Vigsnes, and Christman present. Chairman Malina and Commissioner Andrews were absent. With five members present, a quorum was established. 2. Public Comment None 3. Certificate of Appropriateness Review A. C.O.A. 23-03 – 132 Fremont Street – City of West Chicago – Façade Renovation Mr. Sterrett stated that Ronald Segert of Norris Segert Funeral Home and Cremation Services, owner of 132 Fremont Street in the Turner-Junction Historic District, is seeking approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness to install a 6-foot tall shadowbox fence. The proposed fence will be located along the western lot line, approximately 107 feet in length, and will match the existing fence located along the side property line south of the funeral home building. The existing fence along the south lot line received COA approval in June of 2022. The proposed fence complies with the City’s Zoning Code. After a brief discussion, Commissioner Christman made a motion, seconded by Commissioner Noland-Rianni, to approve the COA application as presented. With a voice vote of all ayes the motion carried. 1 ===== PDF PAGE 38 ===== [Extraction: embedded PDF text] B. C.O.A. 23-05 – 312 E Washington Street – Revolution Solar – Solar Panels Mr. Sterrett stated that Cherissa Marzano-Gabriel of Revolution Solar has applied for approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness on behalf of Holly Perez, owner of 312 East Washington Street in the East Washington Street Historic District, to install 10 roof-mounted solar panels on an existing detached garage on the property. Seven of these panels will be installed on the rear of the structure and will not be visible from public view along East Washington Street. The remaining three panels will be installed on the roof facing East Washington Street and will be visible from public view. No panels will be installed on the existing single-family home. Commissioners raised concerns about allowing solar panels that are visible from the public right- of-way within the East Washington Street Historic District. The Commission requested more information from applicant as to why solar panels needed to be located on the street side of the detached garage sine there was no indication in the application as to why this is needed. Commissioner Noland-Rianni made a motion, seconded by Commissioner Christman, to continue the discussion to the next meeting pending more information from the applicant. With a voice vote of all ayes the motion carried. C. C.O.A. 23-04 – 425 E Washington Street – Robert Collier – Detached Garage Demolition Mr. Sterrett stated that Robert Collier, homeowner of 425 E Washington Street in the East Washington Street Historic District, is requesting approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness to demolish the existing two-story detached garage on the property. The homeowner previously applied for and received approval of a COA to demolish this garage in July of 2016. A building permit was subsequently applied for and approved for this demolition. The demolition, however, did not occur and the approvals for the demo permit and the COA have since lapsed. The garage has horizontal wood clapboard siding and a gable roof covered in asphalt shingles. The garage has a severe lean to it and has been determined to be structurally unsound. The building is considered a hazard and was placed in violation instructing either its immediate removal or repair. An evaluation of the structural integrity has concluded that it is more cost effective to remove the existing garage in its entirety in lieu of correcting the structural deficiencies and restoring the structure. Furthermore, the garage is classified as legal non-conforming as it does not comply with the current minimum side yard setback requirement of three (3’) feet from the side (west) lot line. In fact, the garage encroaches over the west lot line and into the neighboring property. The homeowner intends to replace the garage if the demolition is authorized by the Commission. A COA will need to be submitted and approved prior to construction of a replacement. The commission had concerns about the demolition of the detached garage because of its historical significance as a carriage house. The commission directed staff to contact the property owner and request three quotes from contractors to determine the cost of repairing the garage. The Commission also wanted to understand what type of garage would be constructed in place of the existing garage. Commissioner Edwards made a motion, seconded by Commissioner Christman, to continue the discussion to the next meeting pending the requested information from the applicant. With a voice vote of all ayes the motion carried. 2 ===== PDF PAGE 39 ===== [Extraction: embedded PDF text] D. C.O.A. 23-06 – 124 Main Street – Yolanda Peterson – Removal of Door Threshold Mr. Sterrett stated that Yolanda Peterson, owner of 124 Main Street in the Turner Junction Historic District, is requesting approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness to remove the threshold of the existing exterior door on Main Street. The building space is currently being renovated for a new bakery known as “Raised Bakery”. The applicant received COA approval in February of 2020 to install a new entrance on the south wall of the building. Because of the addition of this door, ADA requirements stipulate that the existing door on Main Street be accessible. For this to be possible, the existing threshold must be removed to satisfy ADA requirements. The applicant is planning to replace the existing door with the same type and style door, just slightly taller so it extends to grade. After a brief discussion, Commissioner Christman made a motion, seconded by Commissioner Vigsnes, to approve the COA application as presented. With a voice vote of all ayes the motion carried. 4. Preliminary Review 132 Fremont Street Mr. Sterrett stated that staff received an application for a stoop/steps removal and replacement at 132 Fremont Street. Mr. Sterrett noted that there is an existing tile on top of the existing stoop. The Commission expressed a desire that this tile remain on the stoop and directed staff to convey this information to the applicant. 5. Approval of the Draft February 28, 2023 Meeting Minutes Commissioner Christman made a motion, seconded by Commissioner Vigsnes, to approve the February 28, 2023 meeting minutes subject to the removal of the first two paragraphs on page 2 since they were part of a previous meeting. With a voice vote of all ayes the motion carried. 6. Other Business Prince Crossing Train Depot Vice Chairman Letsche brought up the future demolition of the train depot building on Prince Crossing Road located on property owned by Wheaton Academy. Mr. Sterrett explained that Wheaton Academy may remove the building as part of overall improvements to their school campus although they have not given a definitive schedule of its removal. The Commission had concerns that they have not yet been consulted in the building’s potential removal. Vice Chairman Letsche informed the Commission on the historical significance of this particular train depot building. In the future the Commissioners want to ensure that they are able to contribute to any discussion related to a decision concerning a historic matter. Next Meeting Mr. Sterrett stated that the next meeting would be on April 18th rather than April 25th. 7. Adjournment Commissioner Vigsnes made a motion, seconded by Commissioner Christman, to adjourn the meeting. With a voice vote of all ayes the motion carried. The Historical Preservation Commission, at 7:11 p.m., adjourned. Respectfully submitted by John H. Sterrett, City Planner 3